Contents
Some negative news stories following Ethereum’s transition to the PoS consensus can and should make anyone wary — is PoS really going to make Ethereum better and safer? In this article, we discuss new and unexpected threats to Ethereum.
Immediately after the merger was completed, US SEC Chairman Gary Gensler warned the Ethereum community that the ETH stacking available after the merger could fall under the Securities Act. The SEC has previously warned Ethereum that the PoS model of operation contains all the hallmarks of a security-asset and therefore should be regulated as required by law.
Under the current Securities Act, cryptocurrency companies that provide crypto-asset stacking services are required to pass the Howey Test.
The brand new newsletter with insights, market analysis and daily opportunities.
Let’s grow together!
To remind you, the Howey Test is used by the courts to determine whether a transaction is an investment contract and falls under SEC jurisdiction (with subsequent mandatory registration).
The final decision remains with the courts, but the SEC itself is of the opinion that crypto assets allowing holders to earn passive income have all the attributes of non-documentary (digital) securities.
Gary Gensler has already given senators a report on about 10,000 cryptocurrencies with securities attributes. The SEC is ready to begin enforcing violators’ registration and is awaiting lawmakers’ assessment.
Because of the importance of this issue, Coinbase has launched an online service that shows how different members of the U.S. Congress rate their attitudes toward cryptocurrency from “very positive” to “very negative.” The algorithm is based on data from third-party service CryptoActionNetwork, which evaluates publicly available data like media statements, legislative initiatives, and willingness to accept donations in digital assets.
Experts so far are opposing in their assessment of possible regulation: some believe that regulation will bring legislative order and open the door to an inflow of new money. In contrast, others quite reasonably believe that the vast majority of crypto projects simply will not meet all the conditions that apply to the circulation of securities.
Most experts are inclined to believe that Gary Gensler’s personal reference to Ethereum is quite an alarming signal. Now we have to wait for the resolution of this situation.
Another negative factor that first appeared after The Merge is the threat of Ethereum centralization.
According to Santiment, more than 45% of the Ethereum nodes launched after The Merge update are managed by just two addresses. This has caused the crypto community a lot of controversy and concerns about the centralization of the project.
In August, similar concerns were shared by Web3 storage infrastructure co-founder Maggie Love, who reported that most of the nodes on the Ethereum network are managed by centralized vendors, including Amazon Web Services (AWS), which dominates the field with a 52.1% share, Hetzner (over 15%) and OVH (4.1%).
This online debate has sparked a wide range of different opinions and possible versions to explain facts:
It is still difficult to say which side is right in this dispute, but we can definitely state that the situation is strange and suspicious. The centralization of any blockchain project is absurd, as it destroys all the advantages of crypto and turns it into an analog of an ordinary online bank.
Considering the potential legal problems mentioned by the SEC chairman, it’s logical to ask whether switching to PoS is the right thing to do. Do the arguments of green mining and sustainability outweigh the new stack of problems that PoS creates? We’ll get the answer to that question from the market in the coming months. For now, the benefits of switching from PoW to PoS are still quite debatable.
Hello, fellow crypto enthusiasts! 👋 As we embark on another week in the ever-evolving crypto…
EigenLayer, a protocol for Ethereum restaking, recently announced an airdrop plan that garnered both praise…
Keonne Rodriguez, a figure linked to the cryptocurrency mixing service Samourai Wallet, has entered a…
The debut of spot crypto exchange-traded funds (ETFs) on the Hong Kong stock market is…
Tether, renowned for its dominant stablecoin USDT, has embarked on a significant investment journey after…
Bitcoin analyst Willy Woo forecasts that the cryptocurrency industry could achieve its first billion users…